Foot and Ankle Arthritis: Answers to Common Questions from Specialist Dr. Brian Law
Our feet and ankles are instrumental in every aspect of our lives. They provide support and balance to our body while we stand, mobility for walking, and shock absorption when we run and jump. The explanation behind the wide range of motion in our feet and ankles can be attributed to their complex anatomy. In one foot alone, there are almost 30 bones and 30 joints operating collectively to enable smooth movement and withstand the significant stress that is required of them every day.

Due to the complexity of the feet and ankles, sometimes treating injuries and conditions in this area is more challenging. Below, Dr. Brian Law addresses some frequently asked questions he receives within his area of expertise regarding arthritis in the feet and ankles.
What is foot and ankle arthritis?
Arthritis is a general term for inflammation of the joints, and it can affect any joint in the body, including the spine, shoulder, hand, hip, knee, foot, and ankle. Arthritis results in the loss of cartilage, which is the smooth, protective tissue that’s on the ends of the bones.
What are the early signs of arthritis in the feet and ankles?
When protective tissue starts to wear away, that is when people start to experience pain. Pain is the first and most common symptom people with arthritis have. Those with arthritis will experience pain with walking and activity. They may also experience:
- Swelling
- Stiffness in the joint
- Limited range of motion in the affected area
- Tenderness or sensitivity around the joint
- The feeling of warmth/heat around the joint
What areas of the foot and ankle are most affected by arthritis?
Because our feet and ankles see a significant amount of wear and tear over time, and arthritis is a condition of gradual deterioration, all areas of the foot and ankle are susceptible to developing arthritis.
There are three different types of foot arthritis, including forefoot arthritis, midfoot arthritis, and hindfoot arthritis.
- Forefoot arthritis is when arthritis affects the front of the foot near the toes.
- Midfoot arthritis is when arthritis affects the middle and top of the foot.
- Hindfoot arthritis is when arthritis affects the back of the foot near the ankle.
Hindfoot arthritis is often confused with ankle arthritis due to the location of the joints: the hindfoot is directly next to the ankle. Some patients are diagnosed with subtalar arthritis, one type of hindfoot arthritis. This type affects the subtalar joint, which is the joint found below the ankle joint in the hindfoot.
What causes arthritis in the feet and ankles?
Wear and tear is the most common cause of arthritis in the feet and ankles. Other factors contributing to arthritis development, not related to gradual degeneration, include previous injuries (post-traumatic), infections that involve a joint, deformities such as flat feet and bunions, and other diseases like rheumatoid arthritis, gout, psoriasis, and lupus.
How is arthritis of the foot and ankle diagnosed?
For someone seeking a diagnosis due to persistent symptoms over a prolonged amount of time, they will be evaluated through a physical exam and imaging. The most common imaging physicians use to diagnose arthritis is an X-ray, as this allows us to visualize the damage to the joints and identify which joints are involved. Sometimes, an MRI or a CT scan is required to help with the diagnosis if the results from the X-ray prove inconclusive.
What are the treatment options for foot and ankle arthritis?
If a patient has a physical exam and imaging that result in the diagnosis of arthritis, the first course of treatment includes conservative treatment options such as anti-inflammatory medications, steroid injections, physical therapy, braces, and shoe modifications. If these conservative treatments do not relieve pain after trying them for a few weeks (typically four to eight), then surgery is always an option.
Surgical options for arthritis in the foot may include “cleaning up” the joint(s) to remove bone spurs, or a fusion for most joints. In the ankle, limited arthritis can be treated with the removal of bone spurs if they are limiting motion and causing pain. For most patients with advanced arthritis, treatment would include a total ankle replacement. It is important to note that a small subset of patients cannot receive a total ankle replacement and may require a fusion of the ankle instead.
What is a fusion? (Ankle fusion vs. ankle replacement)
A fusion is a type of surgery where the ends of the bones at a joint are made to grow together to become one solid bone. For the bones to grow together, the affected joints need to be prepared, which involves making the ends of the bones raw to simulate a broken bone in the body, promoting healing. The bones are then held together with plates, screws, or rods until the bones naturally grow together. A fusion eliminates the motion in the joint; however, it also relieves the pain.
What are the differences between braces, orthotics, and shoe modifications as conservative treatment options?
There are a variety of braces that can be used as a conservative treatment option for foot and ankle pain. Common braces that are used include the Arizona Brace, Arizona Mezzo Brace, Richie Brace, and Ankle-Foot Orthosis (AFO). While the Arizona Mezzo Brace and Richie Brace allow for movement in the ankle, the Arizona Brace and AFO limit motion in the ankle. Unless there is a problem with the ankle, the braces that leave the ankle free for movement are a preferred choice.
Orthotic inserts (like the Morton’s Extension Insert) and a rigid orthotic (like braces) are used to limit motion of the affected joints, protecting them from movement, which can relieve pain. Generally, braces are recommended over orthotics simply for insurance reasons. Braces are covered by Medicare and insurance, while orthotics are not. This means that patients must pay out of pocket for orthotics.
Wearing a tennis shoe with a rocker bottom is a shoe modification that can alleviate some pain within the foot. The rocker bottom acts like a rocking chair, which limits the motion of the joints in the foot, while still allowing the foot to roll, giving individuals a better gait. It provides protection while limiting motion to help with pain.
How does total ankle replacement surgery work?
The only joint in the foot and ankle that reliably does well with a joint replacement is the ankle. A total ankle replacement is performed either under general anesthetic or via a nerve block and involves cutting the bone to allow for placement of the components that recreate the ankle joint.
When performing an ankle replacement, the end of the tibia (shin bone) and the top of the talus (the bone that rotates the ankle) are removed and replaced with metal components. Placed between these metal components to act as a bearing surface is a piece of high-grade polyethylene plastic. Replacing the joint eliminates pain from the arthritis but maintains motion in the ankle. In many cases, motion in the arthritic ankle joint is improved because of the ankle replacement.
Patients who require an ankle joint replacement will have a total joint coordinator assigned to them to help guide them through their joint journey.
How long do ankle replacements last?
Ankle replacements have been shown to last 10-15 years. Advances in design, materials, and techniques have helped to improve durability in modern ankle replacements, with some replacements lasting more than 20 years.
When should I consider surgery for foot or ankle arthritis?
At OSMS, our physicians operate on less than 30% of our patients; therefore, surgery is only recommended when it is necessary. However, surgery is ultimately a personal, quality-of-life decision. When the pain and limitations in motion are affecting your quality of life to the point where you are fed up with it and want to restore your function and quality of life, then we are happy to take care of you and discuss your options.
For those wanting a more in-depth look at foot and ankle arthritis, watch the recorded webinar on Arthritis of the Foot and Ankle. During his presentation, Dr. Brian Law explores what arthritic conditions can develop in the foot, signs and symptoms to be aware of, and the conservative and surgical treatment options available.
Can ankle arthritis be cured?
Although arthritis is a chronic condition that cannot be reversed, people experiencing symptoms of arthritis do not simply have to “deal with it.” Pain is not a symptom of aging, and there are multiple effective ways that arthritis pain can be managed so that individuals can continue to maintain mobility and live an active lifestyle.
If you’re experiencing pain in your foot and/or ankle, our orthopedic foot and ankle specialists can provide you with an accurate diagnosis and develop a treatment plan. Your plan will be unique to you and focused on getting you back to living the life you love—pain-free! Schedule an appointment with one of our Northeast Wisconsin orthopedic foot and ankle specialists today.






















